Shogun 2’s unrealized potential
I spent another 30 hours in Shogun 2, and while I still hold it as one of my favorite Total War games, the recent remaster certainly opened up a fascinating conversation about what gets updated in an already masterful strategy title. There is something wonderfully straightforward and elegant about the original game, a simplicity that makes the subsequent additions—or lack thereof—all the more notable.
Creative Assembly opted for a remaster with modern visuals, updated unit controls, and full Japanese voice acting. While these additions certainly polish the experience, the real debate lies in whether the changes fundamentally enhance the game or simply layer new features onto an already fantastic foundation.
Taking a deep dive into the new content revealed several areas where refinement could have truly elevated the experience. For instance, the introduction of 50 new minor factions provided a huge opportunity, yet these clans lacked unique bonuses or defined playstyles. Without some mechanism to distinguish them, the new factions felt somewhat interchangeable. Furthermore, the trade system, which proved less accommodating for single-region island factions, lacked the necessary quality of life tweaks expected in a game of this depth.
The standout improvements were the changes to the endgame, including the “Realm Divide” difficulty options, enhanced visuals, and reworked unit controls. These changes brought a noticeable visual upgrade, especially in the battlefield presentation. However, some additions felt tacked on. Features like the diplomatic quick deal proved largely unnecessary given how infrequently alliances or trade agreements were necessary in the campaign, and the option to arrange marriages was also overlooked.
For players focused purely on mechanics, there were critical Quality of Life improvements that were conspicuously absent. I found myself wishing for simple features like the ability to merge units and a clearer numerical indicator for army strength, which would eliminate tedious counting during attritional warfare.
Beyond internal mechanics, the remaster could have addressed several technical issues that have plagued the game for years. Bugs related to pathfinding, defensive naval AI, and general AI inconsistencies persist. While the developers released a list of bug fixes, the cumulative number of documented issues suggests that there remains a substantial amount of work yet to be done.
Ultimately, Shogun 2 remains a stellar strategy title. Whether you enjoy battling with samurai or unloading rifle infantry into enemy armies, the core experience is still phenomenal. The game’s enduring quality is not contingent on the remaster; it simply is. The fantastic DLC factions, like the Christian Otomo or the cannon-toting Saga, still offer spicy campaigns for newcomers, and they remain a rewarding way to explore the world of feudal Japan.
If you own the original game, there is a great opportunity to revisit it. Owners of the original game will receive all the legacy faction DLC for free, and there is a significant discount available when the Complete Edition launches on Steam. It is a testament to the game’s quality that it continues to captivate players and inspire further evolution.
Buy on Amazon
Credit
